One's a national chain, serving hand-cut steaks. One's a local joint, cozily located downtown, serving luscious steaks. One's in Meridian, meaning you'll drive a little, but eat a lot, given the high marks they get for their steak. One's a brisk walk away from the Idaho State Capitol, making it a good hideout for local politicos or for those who just want to appear that way.
Second Place: Stagecoach Inn
Third Place: Chandler's steakhouse