The Great (Latter-day) Gatsbys 

I have not yet seen the Baz Luhrmann adaptation of The Great Gatsby, which I'll admit is mostly because I'm scared to watch it. Since the previews started showing up, I cringed at the Luhrmann razzle-dazzle--Jay Z meets J.G.?--that gave Shakespeare and 1880s Paris a case of neon-infused hysteria.

All the same, I've always been an F. Scott Fitzgerald enthusiast, reading Gatsby at least once a year since high school and owning compilations of his magazine work, short stories and (almost) all his novels. I even sat down the other night, in lieu of going to the theater for Gatsby on Steroids, and watched the 1974 film starring Robert Redford as Gatsby, Mia Farrow as Daisy Buchanan and Sam Waterston as Nick Carraway.

Without having seen Luhrmann's cinematic take on the novel, I won't try to compare the films. But in re-watching the older version, I was again left with that sickened feeling of excess--the frantic, dissolute characters; their exhausting histrionics; the champagne-drenched falsity of their ludicrous mansions; their spoiled self-destruction.

The spectacle is a soul-wearying one, as Fitzgerald intended, and with that hollow sensation fresh in my mind, I decided that not only is The Great Gatsby the perfect novel for our time, Baz Luhrmann is probably the perfect guy to adapt it to our age of high-speed superficiality, which is well served by the Luhrmann style: hip-hop! 3-D! research trips on ocean liners! The film opened with receipts topping $51 million, a Gastby-worthy figure for what I'm sure is a Gatsby-worthy spectacle.

Wealth and the worship of wealth is the lodestone of the Gatsby universe, and the perversion of that fixation corrupts everything--from fashion to love to art--and even (spoiler alert) ends up costing a few people their lives. That might sound like a lot of moralizing, but you don't need to look any further than the news to see a vivid example of how the First World's addiction to luxury fuels tragedy in the Third World.

More than 1,000 workers died in the collapse of a Bangladesh garment factory in late April, which--in eight stories of the most primitive conditions--churned out fashionable clothing for Western consumption.

We like to think slavery is a historic evil, but the fact remains that millions toil daily to support the hyper-speed, high-fashion lifestyle that we latter-day Gatsbys seem to think is vital. Don't believe me? Take this get ready for your own noveau riche hangover.

Pin It

Readers also liked…

  • Crime and Punishment in Payette County

    To say "this kind of thing doesn't happen in America" is to ignore a brutal reality: At a certain point, your elected officials would rather see you shut up in jail than expressing your opinions.
    • Nov 19, 2014
  • Dam Big

    Ours is a thirsty land.
    • May 20, 2015
  • Share and Share Alike

    For insight into the sharing economy, we look back to the fourth grade.
    • Oct 8, 2014


Comments are closed.

Join the conversation at
or send letters to

Latest in

  • Date Saving

    Our Black-and-White Photo Contest and The Big LeBoise
    • Apr 27, 2016
  • Sometimes It Matters

    Journalism gets a bad rap, but it's also significant
    • Apr 20, 2016
  • Turning on the Lights

    Idaho's connection to the "Panama Papers"
    • Apr 13, 2016
  • More »

From the Archives

  • Back to Business

    This week, it's back to business, literally.
  • Not So Fast

    By the time this publishes on Wednesday, April 3, the Legislature may or may not have adjourned, and all because--it looks to me--like some key backers of the voter-defeated "Luna Laws" education reform package are using a spat over committee turf to squeeze some sour grapes.
  • More »

Most Shared Stories

© 2016 Boise Weekly

Website powered by Foundation